Blog · November 2026

Category: Fees & Pricing

Card Fee Court Cases in the News: What Could Change for Your Business?

Two court cases about card fees are in the news: a proposed settlement over card acceptance rules that still needs a judge's final approval, and an appeals court ruling on the federal debit fee cap. Neither changes your fees or rules automatically today. Read your statement and ask your provider in writing how any change may apply.

A plain summary of a proposed card fee settlement and a debit fee ruling, what is still undecided, and what to ask.

Keepwell Payments graphic with the headline "Card fee court cases: what could change?" next to a sample note titled "Card fee news" with the line "Ask in writing" highlighted.

You may have seen headlines this fall about card fees and the courts. Here's a plain summary of two cases, what is still undecided, and what a local business can do now. It reflects public court documents as of Nov. 17, 2026.

What is the proposed card fee settlement?

A class action over card fees has been in federal court in New York (the Eastern District of New York) for many years. Lawyers for merchants and the two major card networks reached a proposed settlement, and the judge gave it preliminary approval in June 2026. The final approval hearing was set for Nov. 16, 2026. As of Nov. 17, 2026, the official settlement website says the court has not yet given final approval, so the changes are not in effect.

According to the settlement website, the settlement would change some rules for businesses that take those networks' cards. Among them, businesses could decline some premium and business credit cards, some credit card interchange rates would be reduced and capped, and there would be an education program for merchants. The website says it has information for businesses that accepted those cards between Dec. 18, 2020, and June 9, 2026, and that class members don't need to file any forms for this settlement.

Whether any change would lower what a particular business pays depends on its provider and its agreement. Results vary.

Would declining some cards help a small business?

Maybe not. Turning some cards away may not help much in practice. Asking a customer for a different card can slow the line, upset the customer and cost the sale, and some premium-card purchases can be larger.

If the settlement is approved, think it through before you act, and talk with your provider before you change which cards you take or what your signs say. The settlement also changes other card rules, and some state laws may apply, so check with your provider and your attorney before you change anything about how you take card payments.

What did the appeals court say about debit card fees?

Separately, on Oct. 26, 2026, the federal appeals court for the Eighth Circuit upheld a lower court decision that throws out the Federal Reserve's current cap on debit card interchange fees. The court said the Federal Reserve counted costs the law tells it not to count, and it sent the rule back to the Federal Reserve to set a new fee structure.

What happens next is not settled. The opinion says the decision takes effect only when the court issues its mandate, after the time to ask for a rehearing runs out or a rehearing request is denied. It's too early to say whether debit card fees for a given business will go up, go down or stay the same.

What should you do now?

  1. Don't change which cards you accept, your prices or your signs based on headlines alone.
  2. Look at your statement so you know what you pay today. Our guide to reading your processing statement shows where card fees appear.
  3. Ask your provider in writing: if the settlement is approved, or the debit cap changes, how would it affect my account? Would any change pass through to me, and when?
  4. Check the official settlement website for updates on final approval.

If you're comparing providers while all this plays out, our list of questions to ask any merchant services provider can help you get answers in writing.

Frequently asked questions

Is the card fee settlement final?

Not yet. The judge gave it preliminary approval in June 2026, and the final approval hearing was set for Nov. 16, 2026. As of Nov. 17, 2026, the official settlement website says the court has not yet given final approval. Check that website for updates.

Should I stop taking premium credit cards?

Not based on headlines. The settlement isn't final, and asking a customer for a different card can cost the sale. If it is approved, talk with your provider before you change which cards you take or what your signs say.

Did a court change debit card fees?

On Oct. 26, 2026, a federal appeals court upheld a decision throwing out the Federal Reserve's current debit fee cap and sent the rule back to the Federal Reserve. What replaces it, and when, isn't known yet.

What should I ask my provider?

Ask in writing how the settlement, if approved, or a change to the debit cap would affect your account, and whether and when any change would pass through to you.

How we approach it at Keepwell

Want to know what you pay today, so you can tell if anything changes later? Send us one month's statement for a free review. We'll walk you through your fees in plain English.

Want us to look at your statement? Upload it at keepwellpayments.com/upload for a free, no-obligation review.

Upload your statement →

Sources

Keepwell Payments, LLC is an independent payments agency. Accounts are set up with a payment processor we partner with, named before you sign. Merchant accounts are subject to approval. Results vary by business. This article is general information, not financial or legal advice.

Get started

See what you pay to take cards.

Get a free review of your current statement, with every fee explained in plain English. No obligation.

Get a free statement review → Keepwell Payments, LLC is an independent payments agency. Accounts are set up with a payment processor we partner with, named before you sign, and are subject to approval.